The Best Weapons for Home Defense: Rifle

What if I told you that the best weapon for home defense may just be a rifle?  I have a good idea of what you’re think­ing and I don’t blame you for being skep­ti­cal. When you typ­i­cally think about weapons for home defense, you usu­ally think of a shot­gun or hand­gun, right?  Stay with me and I’ll explain why I believe a rifle is one of the best options for home defense.

Best Weapons for Home Defense: Rifle

First, a rifle can be used for much more than defend­ing your­self and your fam­ily dur­ing a home inva­sion or bur­glary.  A rifle can be used for urban sur­vival sce­nar­ios where you might have to hunt for food or defend your home from an angry, hun­gry mob.  The home defense rifle is very ver­sa­tile, mak­ing it ideal for addi­tion to any home’s arse­nal.  Fol­low­ing are sev­eral tips that will help you choose the best rifle…

Length of a Home Defense Rifle

The longer the bar­rel of your rifle, the eas­ier it is to con­trol dur­ing rapid fire.  How­ever, the longer your rifle, the more dif­fi­cult it may be to maneu­ver in close quar­ters, shoot­ing around cor­ners, or respond­ing quickly in door­ways, tight rooms, or hall­ways.  Most of the semi-automatic rifles that are used for home defense will have an over­all length of 33–37 inches.  This seems to be the ideal com­pro­mise between close quar­ters maneu­ver­abil­ity and control.

What Cal­iber Should the Rifle Be?

When peo­ple talk about the best cal­iber ammu­ni­tion and the best weapon for home defense, a big debate is inevitable.  Even though you will find as many answers as the num­ber of peo­ple you ask, it really depends on the sit­u­a­tion and your per­sonal needs.  If you live in an apart­ment or are con­cerned about shoot­ing through a wall and into a child’s bed­room, which is some­thing every­one should think about, you may want to stick with a 5.56 car­bine ammo load.  This load has less over-penetration than most hand­guns.  There’s actu­ally a good case for using a car­tridge as low as 22LR.  When this is aimed well, it is pow­er­ful enough for home defense.  Addi­tion­ally, the ammo is light, allow­ing you to carry large amounts if nec­es­sary, such as when you might find your­self in sur­vival situation.

Gad­gets and Giz­mos for a Home Defense Rifle

While you might be tempted to start adding laser sights and scopes to your rifle, I really don’t think these extras are nec­es­sary in order to have the best weapon for defend­ing your home.  With that being said, it wouldn’t hurt to have access to a scope that can be used in wilder­ness or urban sur­vival sce­nar­ios.  Most impor­tantly, take some time to train in close quar­ters with your rifle so you will know exactly how it will func­tion.  Learn­ing how to use the rifle will ensure that you really do have the best weapon for home defense.

Home Defense Tac­tics With A Rifle

Firearms enthu­si­asts love to debate the best weapons, loads, and gad­gets for home defense weaponry.  How­ever, the very best weapon in your hands is only as use­ful as your abil­ity to know what to do with it to make the bul­let find its tar­get.  Range prac­tice is impor­tant but for home defense, the rules change com­pletely.  Cre­at­ing a “safe room” from which to defend… estab­lish­ing “fatal fun­nels” for bad guys to screw up in… and how to escape from home invaders that have taken you hostage… these are strate­gies that go far beyond just choos­ing the best weapon.  For all you need to know about sur­viv­ing a home inva­sion sce­nario, check out our web­site at www​.Home​De​fense​Tac​tics​.com.

Tags:

55 Comments

  1. Milan says:

    Myself spent twenty years in the Army and now do not have any rifles or hand­gun in the home. I just get along with­out them. My wife does not like them in the house.

    • Joe LittleBear says:

      Pres­i­dent Ronald Regan once said ” Crim­i­nals PREFER unarmed victims.….it makes their cho­sen pro­fes­sion much safer.…” Lis­ten to your wife.…if you are the vic­tim of a home invasion„„,you, she and all your chil­dren will be at the com­plete mercy of your attackers.…what will fol­low is too graphic to describe..and it will be too late for her con­fes­sion that she didn’t know what she was talk­ing about.…she just thought it would hap­pen to some­one else.….As a mem­ber of a Sher­iff Dept , I have wit­nessed hard­ened Deputies lose their break­fast while inves­ti­gat­ing the after­math of such a scene.…

      • you says:

        What in the **** Joe? What on earth are you try­ing to do with that com­ment. I think you need a tranq shot in your a*s man jesus H. Are you try­ing to scare Milan into own­ing a gun? That is not the way to do it. I would seek therapy.

        • WOW... says:

          Come on, his mind set wasnt to scare him into own­ing a gun, it was to get him out of the mind­set that noth­ing will ever hap­pen to his home/family, EVER. Which really does make it an easy pro­fes­sion for crim­i­nals to stay in. I’m 25, I have 15yrs of mar­tial arts expe­ri­ence, 5 of them were spent teach­ing, I am also a pro-mma fighter, yet I still own a Benelli shot­gun as well as a Glock 22. It’s best to be safe & pre­pared but not hys­ter­i­cal & crazy.

      • Vlad says:

        Milan, I do not believe you. Either your say­ing that for fun to get a rise out of folks, or your say­ing that to pro­pa­gan­dize folks. Since your in a defen­sive firearms forum.. imo odds are your an anti-gunner/agent provacateur.

        Vlad

      • Jacob says:

        Do you also mur­der dogs and never pro­tect the pub­lic like most worth­less, cow­ard, steroid addict cops?

    • rubenoff says:

      we dont need guns here eithere peo­ple are trust­wor­thy
      If we need on we woulf get a 12 gauge shot­gun with oump action and 4 shot,s in the mag­a­zine and a few spare bullets

      even an untyrained per­son can fire a shot­gun and with all the pel­lets the guy on the reciev­ing end will be there when the police and hurse arrive’s

  2. ding says:

    I’d have to dis­agree here jeff, a rifle being use­ful in almost any sit­u­a­tion is not one I would have as being my only tool for home defense, when you talk about a sur­vival sce­nario a ruger 10/22 and a rem 700 in 30–06 is great because real­ity is that every­body has one and ammo is plen­ti­ful. but as far as home defense the over pen­e­tra­tion of even a .223 rem would be too much. through one wall is too much to go through. A pis­tol would be great but not with lit­tle kids around. Espe­cially these tac­ti­cal Tup­per­ware guns like glocks and xds, they are made for the idiot shooter and there­fore chil­dren could oper­ate them too easily.

    I’d say a good ole pump shot­gun using 7 1/2 bird­shot would be fine in 99% of home inva­sions. Bur­glars don’t go in expect­ing a gun fight and prob­a­bly wouldn’t have body armor of any kind so there would be no real need for high pow­ered rifle rounds or buck­shot and slugs. Another advan­tage to the shot­gun is that it works almost every­time with very lit­tle main­te­nance, the aver­age joe is going to stow what­ever he picks as his “home-defense” weapon up high in a closet where it will get dusty and rusty until the need is very dire, so very lit­tle main­te­nance is a must. Another thing is that the shot­gun espe­cially with a shorter bar­rel will be very for­giv­ing in the accu­racy depart­ment, 99% of peo­ple will have had zero weapons train­ing much less any sort of com­bat expe­ri­ence and can­not be expected to deliver a con­trolled pair to the chest in a real sit­u­a­tion. Give them some­thing that they are con­fi­dent with in a high stress situation.

    How­ever at the end of the day no mat­ter what you are using, its a non-aerodynamic brick with­out knowl­edge behind it. Train­ing is the real answer and then lots of prac­tice, with prac­tice comes con­fi­dence
    visit http://​www​.pre​ci​sion​ri​fle​work​shop​.com for some train­ing options

    • Thanks for your com­ment Ding. I actu­ally did write another arti­cle about the home defense shot­gun, and it’s actu­ally my weapon of choice. This arti­cle is meant to offer an alter­na­tive to the shot­gun, which does have it’s dis­ad­van­tages as well.

      In the end, you must come up with the best weapon for home defense for YOU — one that is easy to wield for any­one who may have to use it — and fits your over­all sur­vival plan whether sur­viv­ing at home or out on the run.

      Thanks for your feedback!

      • Rick says:

        Gads, all of you have your opin­ions and you are inti­tled to them. There really is noth­ing like the sound of some­one rak­ing a round of ammo into a shot­gun to make one think about the fool­ish­ness of being in the wrong end of the bar­rel. It is par­tic­u­larly loud in the mid­dle of the night in a quiet house! And that hand­gun is for the close in work.…..does not have to be of large cal­iber to be effective.…remember, it , the home assault, nor­mally takes place some­where within 6–8 feet and in the dark or dim light. Just as crim­i­nals like it.

        • DanL says:

          A good friend of mine was mur­dered by his fiances ex with a Rugar .22 semi-auto. She was par­tially par­a­lyzed for life. The killer had been an AP, then tran­si­tioned to beat cop when he got out of the Air Force.
          Train­ing, train­ing, train­ing. Even a .22 is deadly if you know how to use it.

    • J T says:

      Hav­ing had some per­sonal expe­ri­ence with the .223/5.56 round dur­ing house sweeps. We found the 9mm iFMj in the MP5 actu­ally had more wall pen­e­tra­tion then the Rem­ing­ton .223 hol­low point rounds. After exten­sive test­ing (our agency) found the ammu­ni­tion choice here was key. The MP5s required a FMJ to feed reli­ably at full auto. A short bar­reled rifle (SBR) with .223 hol­low points is a much bet­ter option then even the best bal­anced hand­gun; with the caveat the oper­a­tor is trained with the weapon sys­tem and has a plan of defense. Hon­estly, I think we can all agree here that proper train­ing and mind­set go fur­ther than the “toys” we employ.

      I was told once dur­ing train­ing “Posers buy guns. Shoot­ers buy ammo.” Train, Train, Train, but prac­tice proper tech­niques and prac­tices. Per­fect prac­tice makes perfect.

  3. Carlos says:

    When we had chil­dren we had no firearms but now I prac­tice almost daily with my 22.

    • Mike Meserve says:

      When I had chil­dren in the house I taught them how to shot. When my son was 6 years old his job was to keep the rabit out of his mother gar­den, which he did with a .22 lf. The truth is that chil­dren and gun do mix well. Teach a child to use a gun,

      • Sully says:

        Mike, I may be one of the very few that agree with you. Teach­ing a kid just how final the result of the use of a firearm is a much needed les­son that is rarely taught. Marks­man­ship is sec­ondary, to respect­ing what even the small­est cal­iber can do, and the final­ity of that action.

        I taught my kids to respect and use firearms just as any­one would teach the use of any tool. Each used a .22 lr to kill a beef cow, it is pretty dra­matic when a 1000 pound ani­mal crashes to the ground dead, with one shot. We don’t teach a kid to use a skil­saw by run­ning it across your hand. That result is pos­si­bly less final, than a gun shot.

  4. steve says:

    Its dark, you’ve just bro­ken into a house hop­ing that the own­ers did not hear the win­dow you smashed, you are walk­ing through the house when all of a sud­den you hear the infa­mous cock of a shot­gun. that would be enough to make me run back the way I came.….I’ll stick to my shot­gun for home defense.

    • you says:

      You are com­pletely incor­rect. This is a famous myth that shot­gun man­u­fac­tur­ers use to sell their guns and peo­ple spread because they think it sounds good. Peo­ple who break into homes are not the type of peo­ple who run from the cock­ing of a gun. Think about the mind­set a per­son is in who has the nerve/balls to break into a home not know­ing if some­one is in there. This is a dan­ger­ous per­son. While I agree that a shot­gun is a good home defense weapon you bet­ter be pre­pared to use it because when that break-in occurs and that intruder doesn’t run away after the **** of your shot­gun like I said — will you have what it takes to actu­ally use the gun you claim you will “stick” with for home defense. 90% of the time peo­ple won’t because most peo­ple just like you bought the gun hop­ing the sound alone would deter the intruder and have no inten­tion of ever using it.

      • Ender says:

        I’ve had a bur­glar break into my house. The sound of a pis­tol slide rack­ing a round into the cham­ber stopped him dead in his tracks. Shot­guns aren’t the only uni­ver­sally rec­og­nized sounds.

        • AK that married me says:

          I thank­fully have never needed to use a firearm in defense, but hav­ing lived in Vegas long enough I have come to real­ize the most impor­tance of own­ing one. I bought a pump action shot­gun just for the sound that it makes before it goes bang. The prob­lem is that the real crim­i­nals are get­ting crafty and most of them who have been around long enough know that they need to get to you before you get to your gun. This means expos­ing you at your weak­ness which as funny as it sounds, is dur­ing day­light hours. It starts with a knock at the door. The per­son dresses as harm­less as pos­si­ble and looks as if they would annoy you more than harm you. As you answer the door the seem­ingly harm­less yet annoy­ing per­son in front of you is gath­er­ing infor­ma­tion like noises in the back­ground, mean­ing some­one else in the house, or pets, any­thing that would give them knowl­edge of what they might be up against. When they have *********** you long enough for what­ever they acted like they rang your door­bell for and have the feel­ing that you may be the only threat in front of them, that’s when they strike with­out any mercy. This is usu­ally done with other accom­plices which are hid­ing out of your view with a weapon meant for you. This is a home inva­sion which in a crim­i­nals mind is the eas­i­est and safest way of con­duct­ing busi­ness, and by the way, that shot­gun I have, is now there’s! That gun might be used in there next home inva­sion plot as well. Guns are a great thing to have on your side, but knowl­edge on how to respect­fully pro­tect your­self and under­stand­ing crim­i­nal trends will help your defense as much as any gun. Real crim­i­nals are not stu­pid and know that most of soci­ety is pack­ing. This is why they need to take you out of the equa­tion before you can do the same to them. Most of them don’t mean to kill you, but if that hap­pens, so be it. I’m not try­ing to scare peo­ple from being friendly, but want to help edu­cate peo­ple to learn how to be as threat­en­ing as any crim­i­nal with­out being dis­re­spect­ful to those who don’t mean you harm.

      • E.A. Murcko says:

        Dear You; Respect­fully, I think your in a dif­fer­ent world than the rest of us. when these type of crim­i­nals are inter­viewed one of the biggest things they fear is if the home­owner is armed. I have NEVER heard of a crim­i­nal say­ing they don’t fear the unknown of a rack­ing shot­gun. I don’t know if you have ever taken a life; nor do I actu­ally care.….. no mat­ter what, the lives you take will always effect you. I do know that I per­son­ally would rather rack it , than attack it. I have found there are thou­sands of peo­ple who “talk the walk” but cant , never have or ever will, “walk the talk”. when you really own the T-shirt; you will under­stand that dis­tinct sound, is so you don’t have to take a life but will if needed. T/C and stay safe you. merc

    • Vinny says:

      If you really believe that then just record the sound on your smart phone and play it back when in dan­ger. Rack­ing a hand­gun also makes a sound as does the shiv­er­ing bones of most peo­ple when faced with an intruder. For those of us who were in com­bat we know that despite the tough talk on gun forums, some guys will run, some will freeze and not do anyt­ing and oth­ers just will not be able to shoot another human and end up hav­ing their gun tak­end away from them. Sev­eral LEO friends of mine said that all too often a gun own­ers gun was taken and used against them because they were not pre­pared to shoot.

  5. Frostchaser says:

    Ok, going to have to respect­fully but seri­ously dis­agree with the author.

    Say­ing one of the rea­sons to choose the rifle for home defense is its ver­sa­til­ity in are­nas other than home defense is like say­ing the best blade for a knife fight is a Swiss Army.

    Should one own a rifle for all the afore­men­tioned rea­sons (hunt­ing, sur­vival, “other”)? Absolutely. Should it be the weapon of choice for home defense? Not in my book.

    With regard to the 5.56x45 round, it’s a suf­fi­cient car­tridge, but the author down­plays the risk of over-penetration. The veloc­ity on that round makes it do strange things even when you hit your tar­get. With chil­dren in a room on the same floor as our mas­ter, I’m not will­ing to roll those dice.

    Hav­ing engaged hos­tile tar­gets with 5.56, it’s loca­tion, loca­tion, loca­tion (and a bit of luck). One-round inca­pac­i­ta­tion is most cer­tainly pos­si­ble but so is a 3-round impact that leaves the tar­get still able to fire back.

    I’ll con­cur whole­heart­edly with your com­ment that even a 22LR is suf­fi­cient with the cor­rect place­ment, but by that token a .22 cal der­ringer is adequate.

    We’re talk­ing home defense sce­nario here, the weight of the ammu­ni­tion is imma­te­r­ial. We’re not talk­ing about your ABL for a three-day dis­mounted patrol in Afghanistan, we’re talk­ing about the one weapon you can grab when woken in the dead of night to neu­tral­ize a typ­i­cal home inva­sion threat. If it’s you vs. a squad infil­trat­ing your home, break contact.

    Con­sider this: if you really have to use a weapon dur­ing a home inva­sion sce­nario, sta­tis­ti­cally you’ll be engag­ing a tar­get with lit­tle prep time, fir­ing in low vis­i­bil­ity and your accu­racy will be fur­ther impaired by an adren­a­line dump.

    Gun bat­tles in the home should be avoided for a mul­ti­tude of rea­sons, there’s no bet­ter place for “one shot, one kill.” If you can hit *********** with one round of 5.56x45, you could also hit *********** with one round 12 ga. 2 ¾ “ 00 buck­shot. That’s one 5.56mm pro­jec­tile vs. 6–8 8mm pro­jec­tiles (assum­ing cylin­der bore at 7m) strik­ing your tar­get. Hit­ting the tar­get with 6–8 pro­jec­tiles (roughly a third larger than 5.56) vs. 1 has a much higher like­li­hood of instan­ta­neous inca­pac­i­ta­tion of the threat, and that’s the name of the game.

    If any of the afore­men­tioned engage­ment fac­tors result in less-than-ideal accu­racy, the shot­gun has a greater chance for lethal­ity with an off-center hit. Don’t get me wrong, at a dis­tance of <3m (before the pel­lets have had the chance to dis­perse), you can eas­ily miss a rushed shot with a shot­gun too. But your per­cent­age chance for single-shot inca­pac­i­ta­tion is greater with a shotgun.

    • I agree on the value of the shot­gun as a home defense weapon. How­ever, the rifle is a very viable alter­na­tive that most peo­ple dis­count too quickly. Over­pen­e­tra­tion con­cerns are depen­dent upon your per­sonal sit­u­a­tion — for exam­ple, you stated you have chil­dren on the same floor. Another sit­u­a­tion may be tight hall­ways in an apart­ment, etc. These types of sit­u­a­tions would lend itself best to a .22LR hand­gun like one of Remington’s as an example.

      As a sur­vival­ist as well as a close com­bat prac­ti­tioner, the low cal­iber assault rifle is brought into the dis­cus­sion for the pur­poses of per­sonal eval­u­a­tion within your home envi­ron­ment and for ver­sa­til­ity in a bugout situation.

      The most impor­tant thing I can offer is that, while weapon and ammo choice is crit­i­cal, it’s nowhere near as impor­tant as hav­ing a response plan in place. Too many gun own­ers are great at get­ting a tight shot group, but it’s using the tac­ti­cal advan­tage of your home defense plan within your house that is the most pow­er­ful. That includes pre­ven­tion as well as response.

      I appre­ci­ate you chim­ing in with your feed­back and opin­ion. Really great info you shared!

      • vermin says:

        You real­ize the first sen­tence of the sec­ond para­graph means that low cal­iber assault rifles are sur­vival­ists and close com­bat prac­ti­tion­ers, right? Your writ­ing is as poor as your posi­tion is non­sen­si­cal.. Why would I want 22LR in tight hall­ways? And why are you now talk­ing about handguns?

      • you says:

        An “assault rifle” is one that is selec­table between semi and fully auto­matic. No, as in 0, civil­ians have access to assault rifles so they have no place is this dis­cus­sion at all.

      • Sully says:

        Jeff,

        All the plans in the world are use­less, unless you are will­ing to put that plan in action. Too many folks are not will­ing, but talk big.

    • Ron says:

      Per­son­ally, I’ve been study­ing this for awhile. I am not a pro­fes­sional nor do I have a lot of expe­ri­ence. But I must say using the shot­gun for home defense would not work for me. It’s front heavy and too awk­ward to han­dle for use in the home for me. And it requires 2 hands to use. I don’t have money for all of the fancy acces­sories. That would prob­a­bly add con­sid­er­ably to the weight as well.

      For me if some­thing is not right in the home, it’s grab a handgun..any hand­gun, turn on the lights and then con­firm all is well with the rest of the fam­ily. I really like the idea of a rifle!

    • Ender says:

      I agree on 5.56 and the pen­e­tra­tion issue. Look at Box​otruth​.com regard­ing sheetrock walls and you will see that even .22LR will punch through dry­wall. That said, I pick my AR15 with M855 ammo for that very rea­son. I am will­ing to teach an intruder the dif­fer­ence between cover and con­ceale­ment the hard way.

  6. Joe LittleBear says:

    Whomever wrote this arti­cle is NOT famil­iar with fiurearms …oth­er­wise they would have not listed bar­rel length as 33 to 39 inches.…that is the over­all length of the weapon includ­ing the shoul­der stock.….Never since the days of the Muz­zle­load­ing Black Pow­der rifles has a mass pro­duced rifle had a bar­rel lenght exceed­ing 28 inches.….average lengths run from 22 inches to 26 inches…WW-2 mil­i­tary weapons were 26 to 28 inches…Carbines were 18 to 20 inches…

  7. Galloglas says:

    Win­ches­ter M-94 in 30/30
    Ruger 10/22
    Any .357 mag Revolver
    Ith­ica M 37 in 12 or 20 ga.
    Ammo is easy to find any­where, they don’t set off hoplo­phobes because these are either hunt­ing or tar­get weapons.
    Since these are NOT “mil­tary assault rifle con­fig­u­ra­tion” or “mil­i­tary assault rifle cal­iber” Local LEO is not likely to become alarmed and local gun laws will allow them.

  8. Vermin says:

    This is just silly. At no point in the arti­cle to you even approach sup­port­ing your conclusion.

    • Vermin says:

      In fact, this isn’t just silly; advis­ing peo­ple to use var­mit rounds in a defense sit­u­a­tion is bor­der­line negligence–especially when there are ways to deal with over-penetration while using rounds that are more effective.

  9. Morris says:

    I think the author explained it in his OP, a rifle is a good alter­na­tive in many sit­u­a­tions. That said, con­sider this. Econ­omy is a fac­tor. I sim­ply can’t afford to stock­pile weapons. Most folks can’t. I can only bud­get in the com­ing year for per­haps two. And while I’d love to get a shot­gun, my choice will be for a good rifle and a good hand­gun. But there are many who can’t even afford to do that, and can get only one gun. In that sce­nario, I also would go for the rifle. It would dou­ble as home defense and hunt­ing tool. There are a few mod­els cham­bered for pis­tol car­tridges, and I’ve always liked the con­cept of a long gun and hand­gun cham­bered for the same ammu­ni­tion. In .45 ACP, you don’t have the issue of shoot­ing through your tar­get into inno­cent peo­ple like your fam­ily, for the most part. and a long gun and hand­gun with the same ammo is logis­ti­cally sim­ple. Sure, if you can afford it, get all the weapons you need. An AR15 or two, sev­eral pump shot­guns, a good selec­tion of hand­guns, and so on. But for those of us on a shoe­string bud­get, the writer makes a good case for the rifle as a pri­mary home defense gun. Espe­cially when it has to dou­ble up and do hunt­ing duty. I’m always going to fear the man who has just one gun. He prob­a­bly knows how to use it.

    • you says:

      There are sev­eral com­ments I’m going to make. I agree with you in regards to bud­get. If you want to hunt and have a home defense weapon and don’t have a lot of money than undoubt­edly a rifle is the weapon to get. But, this arti­cle was about home defense not about hunt­ing. Home defense is in the title of the arti­cle. The next point I’m going to make and this can be ver­i­fied as accu­rate with spend­ing any time at all Googling is that peo­ple with more expe­ri­ence with weapons rec­om­mend rifles for home defense. Jeff is a vet­eran and I’m assum­ing your dad prob­a­bly took you hunt­ing as a kid or at the very least you have a good amount of expe­ri­ence with guns that you have accu­mu­lated through the years on your own. That is fine, you under­stand how to load a mag­a­zine and have expe­ri­ence work­ing with them and putting them into a gun. Think about a per­son with hardly any expe­ri­ence with guns. Again, this arti­cle was about home defense and a per­son with hardly any expe­ri­ence with guns is going to be shak­ing like crazy under a real life sit­u­a­tion. ****, those of us with expe­ri­ence will be shak­ing but imag­ine some­one with hardly any expe­ri­ence. They are going to be shak­ing worse than us and you really are going to rec­om­mend they try to fum­ble around and get the mag­a­zine into the rifle under such a sit­u­a­tion? I have spo­ken with sev­eral peo­ple who have been in real life home inva­sion sit­u­a­tions, and these are pro­fes­sion­als who have worked with guns their entire lives, and sev­eral of them couldn’t prop­erly get the mag­a­zine in their hand­guns they were shak­ing so badly. The best weapons for home defense will always be a shot­gun. A pump motion is one that any­one can accom­plish even under high stress. Every­one always has a par­tic­u­lar weapon they rec­om­mend and have par­tic­u­lar rea­sons why they rec­om­mend such weapons but the only thing that mat­ters is what weapon can you oper­ate when your hands are shak­ing so badly you can hardly hold the gun. I’ve yet to see any­one who’s been in a home inva­sion sit­u­a­tion rec­om­mend a home defense weapon. It’s always peo­ple who think what the best weapon would be and come up with all kinds of rea­sons why a par­tic­u­lar weapon is best. Yes, you can think clearly now and can come up with all the answers to why you chose your weapon right now. Think you will be able to think clearly under a real life home inva­sion sit­u­a­tion? Not in a mil­lion years. If you think you will be able to you have absolutely no idea what you are talk­ing about.

    • Sully says:

      If you are look­ing for a one size fits most sit­u­a­tions., the .44 mag or .44/40 Car­bine and hand­gun, is per­haps best aside from the 12 Ga shot gun in which I use #1 for home protection. .

      The .223 with a reload SX bul­let will explode inside a pigeon and not break a win­dow behind it. That comes from expe­ri­ence, not talk. A rather enlight­en­ing expe­ri­ence at that.

  10. Brad says:

    The best weapon is the one that suits your needs, right? For me, its the Kalash­nikov. I had a 590 Moss­berg for awhile, but the kick was too extreme for my wife, and in our home, the length was a prob­lem. We live in a tight cor­nered rancher, with the bed­rooms at the end of the house. Yea, you can put a pis­tol grip on, but then you lose that back up curb­stomp abil­ity of a metal buttplate. As far as pen­e­tra­tion into the kids room goes, only one wall in the house led that way, and it wasnt a pos­si­ble path for an intruder. So I chose a AK for its high power, short over­all length (shorter than any 18″ shot­gun), the unmatched reli­a­bil­ity of the weapon, and my wifes equal skill in using the weapon. For us, the Kalash is a per­fect choice for our home.

  11. joe namath says:

    RUGER mini 14 with 20 or 30 round clip– with tac­ti­cal stock– choice of law enforce­ment in many states– espe­cially Cal­i­for­nia– low kick– and reli­able as the m-14– light enough any­one can fire it– with stock about 18″ long– easy load clips– safety is in front of the trig­ger gaurd– and loud– the crim­i­nal will be won­der­ing what the heck youu are com­ing at them with—- and you will be bet­ter armed than your local offi­cer with his glock pea shooter— who could be many miles away— response to my home would be over 40 minutes.

  12. Neal Bigwood says:

    “Clip” and “Kick” LOL

  13. hov says:

    44mag henry lever. Need i say more, rural set­ting, easy to oper­ate, good for wood­chuck to black bear

  14. A says:

    Good arti­cle. Some good com­ments and lots of stu­pid ones. Every­thing has its place whether it’s rifle, shot­gun, pis­tol, knife, base­ball bat, or the d*** remote in your hand when some­one breaks in. The mind is the best weapon and safety any man can pos­sess, unfor­tu­nately the other weapons aren’t biased to stu­pid­ity and lack of train­ing, and nei­ther is/are the attacker/s. Best advice make a plan, prac­tice with every­one involved, and be will­ing and able to act.

  15. Rick says:

    I have every­thing in my gun safe from my sin­gle shot Rem­ing­ton .22 Model 41, my first gun as well as my dad’s, all the way to a 12 gauge Win­ches­ter 870, and a bunch in-between includ­ing my first shot­gun (a .410, nat­u­rally), a Moss­berg 20 gauge, a Rem­ing­ton 742 semi-automatic 30–06, a Colt 1911 Com­bat Com­man­der in .45 ACP, and oth­ers. While the Colt 1911 is nor­mally handy, IF I had time, I’d likely pre­fer to grab my Marin 336 in .44 Mag or maybe even in 30/30, depend­ing on which one was clos­est. As far as rack­ing the slide, pump­ing a shot­gun, or mak­ing noise with the lever action — I would hope to do so qui­etly to avoid telling the bad guy exactly where I am! ;)

  16. Rob says:

    I have been in two home iva­sions once as a child and once when i was 17. As a child my dad pulling back the lever on his sin­gle action 357 was enough for the intruder to give up. When i was 17 i had already shot many times and knew my guns. Infact the Intruder was not happy to see me at the front door with a .22 car­bine and my dad at the back with his hunt­ing shot­gun. My take on it know your gun know your plan My round was cham­bered saftey was off and had ten­sion on the trig­ger. In my mind i would have to issue fully committing

  17. max says:

    Every home should have some bone saws and rolls of plas­tic wrap for perp dis­posal.
    What­ever gun you use should have a silencer — no point dis­turb­ing the neig­bours — or alert­ing any pos­si­ble look­out who you will also have to dis­pose of.

    If you have to pro­tect your home the entire soci­ety will just give you grief about it and try to ruin your life .
    The first threat is the perps.
    The sec­ond threat is the author­i­ties that will call your defense of self as crim­i­nal.
    The third threat is the social com­mu­nity that will ‘dis­agree’ and harass you or worse for your defense of your­self.
    The role of law in soci­ety is to pro­tect the social sta­bil­ity under the rule and own­er­ship of the rich — this means that self– defense is frowned on and the rulers would rather have a defense­less easy-to-manipulate soci­ety.
    The law is owned by the rich and owned by power inter­ests with their own agen­das and does not serve uni­ver­sal jus­tice.
    ..
    You can only trust your­self to have your own inter­ests in mind.
    No one cares about you and yours except you.

    Act accord­ingly.

    • DanL says:

      Sound like you have the “Liv­ing in Cal­i­for­nia” expe­ri­ence, where the crooks have all the legal rights and us hon­est work­ers have none.
      I like your attitude.

  18. Me says:

    Sure are a lot of com­pen­sat­ing folks on this site who appar­ently get robbed at least three times a month. We all get it.…you’ve got a set of nads.…congratulations. If you’re tru­ely con­cerned with home defense opt for a weapon that you are com­fort­able with oper­at­ing, train, train, train, and train some more. Just as impor­tantly if it’s tru­ely for home defense it will have to be acces­si­ble at a moments notice and for the indi­vid­u­als with chil­dren that means acces­si­ble with ammo. What good is a defen­sive weapon stashed in the top of a closet with the ammo stuck behind the head­board? Last if youre not will­ing to dis­patch an intruder with­out regret maybe you should opt for adding an extra dead bolt to the doors and putting up some secu­rity bars. Heck cam­eras and light­ing can be pur­chased at bar­gain base­ment prices these days.

  19. brahms says:

    A shot­gun is Ok for a man but I think its too much recoil for a woman. In a hyper-stressful sit­u­a­tion, I ‘d pre­fer a low recoil 10/22 with a high cap mag­a­zine (I’m a girly-man). The other prob­lem is capac­ity — you get 5 shots with an aver­age shot­gun and then you’re through. I am not one who believes you need “stop­ping power”; it is more impor­tant to max­i­mize the chance of putting rounds on tar­get — bad guys don’t run at you after being shot by a .22 rifle, they run away (con­trary to pop­u­lar opinion).

  20. R Sullivan says:

    You do real­ize that many states require that you have to be in per­sonal jeop­ardy, with a .22 lr an unin­vited visitor/thief/whatever he can keave your pre­me­sis, from there he can lie about you and his inten­tions. It is far bet­ter to be juudged by 12 than car­ried by 6.

  21. DK says:

    Leave a hand gun (loaded with blanks) in plain site for the har­m­doer to use. Vic­to­rios war­riors win first, then go to war. Sun Tzu.

  22. Gary says:

    Every­one has a pref­er­ence, no big deal. Use what­ever you are com­fort­able with and can use effec­tively.
    I am won­der­ing though, do any of you under­stand the dif­fer­ence between the uses of “then” and “than”? “Then” has ref­er­ence to time, while “than” is a com­par­i­son. Just say­ing.
    Addi­tion­ally, it might be a good idea for some of you to use “spell-check” before post­ing, you won’t “appear” so ignorant.

Leave a Comment





More from:

Jeff Anderson

Jeff Anderson is a 10 year veteran of the U.S. Army, a Master Fitness Trainer, and Master Instructor of Close Quarters Combat self defense. A full time fitness and self defense author, Jeff has trained thousands of men and women in the practical application of advanced military fitness methods as well as close combat tactics for "real life" self defense.

To see more from Jeff Anderson, check out the following websites: